I have argued before that I have not used the language of Christian Nationalism to identify myself. Here are some reasons why.
Am I a Christian Nationalist? + Interview with Lennox Kalifungwa on Christian Eloquence
Two Cities, Two Kingdoms, One Question
The recent conference, including Alex Jones, Nick Fuentes, etc., is probably sufficient reason to make my point that there is a stream of Christian Nationalists that makes AOC sound reasonable. Here is my initial cautionary note that stirred a few friendly and enemy fires.
I begin by simply noting that my theocratic bona fides are untouched. Since my earliest days, I have been unmoved in my ecclesial convictions, elaborated by dear friends like Peter Leithart, James B. Jordan, and Rich Lusk, with all the cautious observations from other friends like Doug Wilson. The low-church Rushdoonyites have never been attractive to me, though their Van Til-ian cultural and philosophical observations go down smooth like Tennessee Whiskey.
So, my response to the Christian Nationalism question is to operate ecclesiastically. The end result of such things has been a panoply of Anabaptist responses—which is hilarious ‘cause this is what Stephen accuses me of— from a host of high-caliber anonymous accounts who have celebrated my demise into Rome. But I am still here in my ecclesial conservatism, wearing my clerical collar and trying to keep up with the patron saint who was quite fond of Mother Church:
“Whence it follows, that revolt from the Church is denial of God and Christ.”
— Institutes, IV.1.10.
And all of this leads me to Stephen Wolfe. He occasionally interacts with those of us in the minor leagues of political online discourse. But for those who don’t know, I’ve known Stephen for a few years. We have shared meals on a couple of occasions, and we have interacted on others. He’s actually an incredibly quiet man who seems to be honest about his position and is sincere about his politics. I’d even go so far as to say that if Stephen lived nearby, we’d probably grab a beer.
That said, he’s offered some concerns about my ecclesiology. And from the tweets above, it seems there are two of them:
First, that I am unaware of the rise of magisterial 2-kingdom thought within my beloved denomination. And secondly, that my ecclesiology is a hybrid of Anabaptist revolution and Roman Catholic integralism, or ecclesiocracy.
So, let me address these two points.
On the first observation, I know Stephen is aware that I was the Presiding Minister of Council from 2023 to 2026. I am now the Pro-Tem PMOC. Up to 2023, I had traveled extensively around the country and other parts of the world, giving lectures, preaching and meeting with officers and parishioners. But then that work accelerated in 2023. I traveled over 100 days a year and visited with thousands of our people around the world. I met pastors and parishioners, enjoyed barbecue in North Carolina and squid in Tokyo (don’t knock it until you try it!), and spent hundreds of hours talking through concerns in these churches. In my calculations, I have visited close to 60 CREC churches and have interacted with another 60 over the years on various platforms.
So, it’s safe to say my awareness of the CREC is big-ly. Furthermore, our congregation here in Pensacola is one of the larger CREC congregations, and we receive a high number of visitors from all over the country, even Canada (eh). The point is, we interact(ed) with the life and breadth of the denomination regularly. And that leads me to Stephen’s observation that there is a rise of classical Two-Kingdom theology in the CREC. I have addressed the Escondido, and by consequence the 2K view here:
Stephen is addressing a very small pool of young men who come dressed in anonymous clothing and who have confessed to him that they are enamored with his book and the idea of a Christian nation, and therefore believe that the Kuyperians and theonomists (BOOMERS!) are out of touch, and that the magisterial Reformers had a more based approach to politics. Well, I happen to think that the magisterial Reformers were correct on the significance of a Christian magistrate, and that they were also correct on their emphasis on Mother Church. Nevertheless, I do not see these ideas conflicting with one another. And to make matters worse, I also don’t find Kuyper’s general societal vision contradictory to that which we pursue. Kuyper demurred from some basic Belgic Confession dogma on the church (Article 36), but I am a big boy and accept that his premise did not keep him from going all in on the Christian vision paradigm. Spit the bones kind of thing. I am simply not an idealist when it comes to the way these things will take place and the chronology thereof; except to say that I know that the Church will be the voice of wisdom and the genesis of all cultural renewal.
So, if there are young men coming into our CREC congregations hungry for national righteousness, then I raise him a II Chronicles 7:14. Bring them in. I have no authority over the CREC, except the respect I have gained from fellow pastors and the affection I hold for them to speak truth. But as for me and my house, we will serve the Lord, and if God brings guys who love our country enough to fight for it, then we will shepherd them. Now, Toby Sumpter has added the caveats here worthy of being considered.
The guys who delight in finding 20 Jooz behind every rock are not going to be at ease in our congregations. Not because the Jooz are sinless, but because they are; but we don't believe they are extraordinarily sinful in comparison with white men in Rhode Island who voted with one voice for the Democratic tickets, or black women who voted with one voice for the socialists. These leftists are all sinful and fallen short, and the Jews are also in the same place, except there are lots of things said about their future that are not said about Rhode Island men (see Bible for reference; yes, all of it). And I can say all these things as a non-Puritan Romans 11 pastor. (See my Man Rampant interview with Doug Wilson on the Jew-question).
And then we come to Stephen’s second observation: that my ecclesiology is causing havoc on the CREC. Where? The denomination at large continues to grow with health, baptisms, and joyful worship. Yes, we may have an expiration date, but as of now, we are trying to count our blessings one by one, times a thousand. And while some don’t like our view on things, we keep pressing on one psalm at a time with covenant renewal worship, weekly bread and wine, deep fellowship, festivities, and yes, church calendar.

But I must confess I am hurt that Dr. Wolfe would call me an Anabaptist. I am not a Baptist, and I don’t believe in double baptisms, and I actually find authority and structure a good thing, and I dare not rebel. Anabaptists functioned autonomously. I submit to a Session and my Presbytery. I abide by my Creeds and Confessions, and if I stray, I am pretty sure I will hear from Elders and Presiding Minister faster than Eric Conn can say, Churchill.
And then the most disappointing thing is that Stephen accuses me of having a Roman Catholic ecclesiology. Really!? As Biden would say, “Come’n, man!”
I grew up in the largest Catholic country in the world, and my ecclesiology resembles none of theirs. I even intend to eat meat even harder during Lent in 2027. My ecclesiology is one that adheres to Calvin’s understanding of the place of the church as inextricably tied to her groom:
“For there is no small weight in the designation given to her, “the house of God,” “the pillar and ground of the truth” (1 Tim. 3:15). By these words Paul intimates, that to prevent the truth from perishing in the world, the Church is its faithful guardian, because God has been pleased to preserve the pure preaching of his word by her instrumentality, and to exhibit himself to us as a parent while he feeds us with spiritual nourishment, and provides whatever is conducive to our salvation. Moreover, no mean praise is conferred on the Church when she is said to have been chosen and set apart by Christ as his spouse, “not having spot or wrinkle, or any such thing” (Eph. 5:27), as “his body, the fulness of him that filleth all in all” (Eph. 1:23). Whence it follows, that revolt from the Church is denial of God and Christ.”~John Calvin, Institutes, IV.1.10
So, Stephen is indeed erroneous for a host of reasons, but I do not view him as a straying brother, and neither will I accuse him of being a fascist authoritarian. And as I stated earlier, we know each other, and chatting again should be simply a matter of seconds.
My high view of the church does not mean a low view of the magistrate. I can affirm both, and I have for some time. My contention is simply that Christian civilization cannot be sustained by political arrangements alone without affection for the Bride of Christ. As I have said before, if the church is an afterthought in your political theology, then everything else will crumble theologically.
Notations
I get these little memes with my face on a regular basis. Some of them are amusing, and others are not so. These guys are not creative at all. I don’t know if JC of Valor is simply a bot or an insecure girl, but ultimately I am simply saying that every alliance has consequences. So, choose your alliance carefully, kids!
Nuntium
For those following my cancer treatment, I cannot thank you enough for your prayers. God has been gracious, and though the side effects remind me of a Stephen King horror movie, they are not nearly as bad as Stephen King’s politics.
Many blessings in Christ Jesus,
Uri











Well said, good and faithful servant.
Pastor, you have done well to stay tempered in the online kiln. It has not gone unnoticed.